MERCH!
Giant Bomb - a website about video games and the people that make them

Aw crap.

by dockjaw on July 22, 2009
5 out of 5 starsScore: 100/100

Uncharted...

Let me just say here that the game is good, great actually, I heartily recommend it. It's the best looking game I've ever played, regardless of pretty rampant pop-in problems, with amazing characterization and animation and story and blah blah blah. Really though, if you own a Playstation 3, or know anyone who does, buy this game. You can play it. It's not anything radical or paradigm shifting, but it's charming and beautiful and funny and almost self aware. It's the George Clooney of videogames. Believe the hype.

So there's this. But there's also that.

I would have liked it if it had been a bit longer. I mean, the game is short, but Naughty Dog did a pretty good job of messing up the pacing already, which is to say that the seemingly endless chains of heart-breakingly frustrating combat make for a good lesson in how not to artificially lengthen your game. These aren't all of my gripes but here are some protips: next time around, don't have such bizarre AI. For example, when I throw a grenade, enemies should turn and run. And when I'm running up on one of those guys to punch his lights out before anyone sees me, it would be nice to not wind up full of bullets before everyone else has even had time to blink. Speaking of running, please make sure Drake doesn't run like an intoxicated bird. It's hard to watch for six to eight hours. And listen, this is a dealbreaker- vary the enemies (and their "witty" one-liners) a little bit more. You're working with a Playstation 3, not Industrial Light and Magic, not every five dudes needs to be a carbon copy. Did you get it? It was a clone joke.

Really though this is my biggest issue: fix the damage system. It shouldn't take a thousand pounds of buckshot to kill three people, especially when it only takes about three rounds from a small calibur rifle to kill me. Maybe I should clarify...the combat system isn't exactly horrendous, it's just not tuned properly. Drake's 'run n gun' thing is entirely luck-based (regardless of cover), the AI is either a perfect shot or completely stupid (no middle ground), and it's impossible to predict if they'll flank you or not (which by the way if they do flank you you're totally screwed because there's basically one safe spot to hang out in during every battle and if you're not in that spot...well...I hope you like ammunition), the fact that bullets and punches do basically the same amount of damage doesn't make any sense at all and hand-to-hand is practically unusable anyway because if (God forbid!) you run out from behind what decrepit, pathetic cover there is to attempt said CQC (or beg for meager scraps of munitions from your adversaries' plentiful, nay, infinite stockpile in their castle high atop Mount Hate) you immediately get porked in the bum by some nameless Mexican Clone Trooper.

 "Not so tough after all!"

You're damn right I'm not. How can you expect me to be?! I am TIRED and FRUSTRATED! I'VE killed about FORTY FIVE of your twin freaking brothers and I ran out of bulletts and grenades after like the sixth one! FUCK YOU.

Woah boy, here's a quick time event.

Oh look, the game's over.

Well that was fun.

The views here are this user’s only and are not representative of Giant Bomb's thoughts and opinions on the discussed video game. GB's official reviews reside at giantbomb.com/reviews.