Rockstar are completely deserving of their name. Along with other
great developers like Blizzard and Valve, the Grand Theft Auto
masters belong to a tier of gaming visionaries who can essentially do
no wrong. Of course, Grand Theft Auto was developed by Rockstar North
whereas Red Dead Redemption was created by Rockstar San Diego, but
the games are very similar in some respects. The biggest things both
games have going for them are their deep, intriguing stories and the
respective worlds that they have these tales take place in. I can't
help but draw parallels to Grand Theft Auto IV over the course of
this review, as the gameplay featured has is supported by many of the
same pillars, but that was already a great game and Red Dead manages
to stand tall beside it. Red Dead Redemption is probably the best
video game ever inspired by the Western genre, and if either the open
world genre of video games or The Good, the Bad and the Ugly (or
both) are to your liking, this game probably is for you.

Much like in GTA, the story progresses by way of missions that various quest-givers tell you to complete. There are multiple smaller stories within the overall branch, and the characters are always interesting and, as is Rockstar's wont, voiced with huge skill by a talented set of voice actors. Standouts are Marston himself, his nemesis Dutch and the police officer that keeps bossing him around throughout the game named Edgar Ross.
The storyline brilliantly portrays the racism, the misogyny and the brutality of those times. As you might expect, the humour is definitely there to keep it all light, but the game treats these themes with the precise amount of seriousness. It is extremely impressive. Again, much like in that car-stealing franchise, the story and its characters in particular is the main drive and one of the two biggest reasons why everyone should play this game.
The other reason is the world itself. Rockstar has really outdone itself here. The Western feeling is portrayed so well that it made me want to go look at some Western movies when I had finished the game. In fact, my respect for the setting has greatly increased after having played Red Dead Redemption, as the Old West was something that I didn't have too much interest in before.
The overworld represents parts of North America and Mexico and is filled with absolutely beautiful sights. I will never forget the first time I rode to the top of one of the mountains and managed to frame the perfect image of the lone rider looking out into the sunset. Red Dead still rolls on pretty much the same engine as GTAIV did, and as such there are games out there that look better, but the vistas were some of the very best I've ever had the pleasure of seeing. Riding across a grassy plain at great speed, chasing after wild horses is an exhilarating experience.

The missions manage to switch things up quite a bit over the course of the game. While any game can be boiled down to “go here, shoot guys, return”, Red Dead always managed to give me a new weapon, an intriguing scenario or a nice environment such as a fortress or a forest to work my way through. The great cutscenes from GTAIV are matched here. You'll grow to hate most of the people attempting to boss John around soon enough, but justice always gets served in the end and the characters are always so interesting that they feel like a reward for performing any given task.

The gunplay has also been retooled ever so slightly since Niko Bellic's adventure. Because the whole game takes place in a transitional era of upcoming technology, there are some classic guns like the Cattleman Revolver and some of the more 'crazy' weapons like sniper rifles and gatling guns. You can take cover and pop out to shoot enemies. If you get into a tight spot, you can use “Dead Eye” to slow down time and mark spots that you're aiming for with little crosses. After you exit Dead Eye, the true gunslinger in cowboy Marston will rise and shoot them all in rapid succession. It's a great and flashy way to quickly get rid of a lot of enemies, and probably one of the most fun mechanics in the game.
There are plenty of missions, strongholds and other random activities to complete. All the gambling games you might imagine in the classic saloon setting are present, and stuff like poker and Liar's Dice double as a great distraction and a source of cash. I reckon I've already spent around two and a half hours just sitting at a poker table, trying to bluff at my NPC opponents. If a mini-game manages to be that compelling, you know that a game is on the right track. Of course, there are some inferior distractions as well, such as a quite plainly terrible horse shoe-throwing side activity.

There is a minor choice system in the game that awards you points for either doing the right thing or being evil and abstaining from putting yourself in danger. Honestly, it seems like moral systems were just fashionable in gaming at the time and that the meter was put in just for that reason, as I noticed no real effects on the gameplay. The only thing that changed was that nuns often came up to me asking for money because I had a good reputation, which seems like it is hardly a reward for helping people out.

Nonetheless, Red Dead Redemption is an absolute gem, and one that you should really play. Its focus on the Old West theme is executed to perfection, its gameplay is fun and its story is one of the best to have come along in recent years, not to mention its ending, which might just be the most satisfying climax I have ever seen to a game. Rockstar San Diego is worthy of commendation for their achievement, and what better way to reward them than by going out and putting down some money for it. It will be worth your while, I assure you.