I liked it, but it didn't have the same awe inspiring moments that made 2 and 3 great.
Probably the best story and setting of any of the uncharted games, I really liked the pyrate lore and the where they went with it, even if it was a bit unbelievable.
The gun fighting was better in this game than it ever has been, I still don't like it, but it's mostly tolerable here.
The rope swinging while stolen from Tombraider, really made the climbing "puzzles" a lot more interesting, a very good addition to the franchise.
The tomb puzzles felt really easy in this game and not very interesting compared to past games.
Overall this was a decent game but I don't think it had the spectacular set piece moments which is one of the most important tenants of the series and that's disappointing.