Eh it doesn't really matter the GotY discussions to me were always just an excuse to hear them talk about some specific games more than actually mattering who got what number.
What is more useful is their personal top ten list combined with knowing their personalities and video game interests. Because actually game of the year final list often ends up just being some weird overly compromised mess with a few games few played but one person was "passionate" about so it must be on there [talking about Invisible Inc here.. it had some serious problems not brought up in their game of the year stream that year, not even mentioned...and I only bought it to try after hearing the passion towards it and it getting on the list... total regret purchase on that one, and I like the genre too!]
Plus then you get into games that are there more for social or political reasons that go way up on the list through this arbitration [as someone else previously talked about in this thread]. While on the flip side with the personal lists you can generally tell who is going to have those games up there by their general personality and vocalness on the site [for purely the social and political reasons] and can ignore those lists due to tastes... or focus on them if that is what truly matters to you in a game, and sift through which person speaks to you best for the lists.
Plus at some point if you are going down the line of pure votes, the issue of not everyone playing every game does become a more important question.
Log in to comment