Final Fantasy XIII: The Breakdown
My time with Final Fantasy XIII didn't exactly get off to the best of starts. I pre-ordered my copy from Amazon.co.uk at the start of February, well over a month before the March 9th release date, hoping to at least get hold of it the day after release, if not on the day. Unfortunately the game took over a week to arrive, finally making it through my letterbox on March 17th. Putting the bad start aside, I popped the first disc into my 360 and booted up the game. What followed over the next couple of months was a fifty-five hour journey that reached its conclusion on May 28th. This blog is an attempt to document that journey, exploring my opinions of pretty much every aspect of the game. Spoilers will be kept to an absolute minimum, and there certainly won't be any major ones over the course of this blog, so if you haven't reached the game's conclusion, don't worry about having it spoiled for you. Given how long it's taken me to write this thing (I started it last Wednesday, believe it or not), this is likely to be a pretty lengthy read. Given the way it's laid out, there's likely to be some overlap between the sections, so I apologise in advance in case I've repeated myself at all. If you're not up for an essay, then simply scroll down to the paragraph titled 'The Verdict' for my final word on the game. The rest of you, let's start with the obvious:
The Graphics
As a 360 adopter, I'm aware that the version of the game I played is the graphically inferior version. Complaints directed at the 360 version as far as I'm aware extended to noticeably jagged textures that are supposed to look layered and feathery (particularly hair), a lower-resolution image, and some artifacting in action-heavy cut-scenes caused by poor video compression. Maybe it's because I was playing on a standard definition TV with a 14-inch screen, but I only ever noticed the first of these problems, and slightly jagged-looking hair is not a game-breaking issue. As a player of Final Fantasy XIII on the Xbox 360, I'm still more than happy to hold up my hand and profess that this is probably the best-looking game I've ever played. If I have to find fault with the visual presentation in any form, then it'd have to be the animations. While characters seem to have been motion-capped with great success for cut-scenes and in-battle, and the Western release gets its own lip-syncing, there's a lot of awkward-looking canned animation and over-gesticulation in the field. I suspect it's a series throwback from the days when sprites used to shake their heads, waggle their fingers and laugh in an overly animated fashion, and thankfully it never gets quite as bad as Tidus' spasmodic hand movements in Final Fantasy X, but it's still noticeable. A minor complaint, though, and one that doesn't detract from the overall point - Final Fantasy XIII is one good-looking game.
The Music
I guess what I'm trying to say is, the music of Final Fantasy XIII isn't particularly memorable. I didn't really notice any particular pieces of music standing out, with two exceptions. The first of these is the battle theme, Blinded By Light, which is appropriately up-tempo and almost annoyingly catchy (I can hear it in my head now as I type). The second of these is the game's main leitmotif, Serah's Theme, which is memorable for much worse reasons. Given I've already cited FFVI and FFVII as boasting my favourite soundtracks of the series, in addition to loving rock operas like Tommy, Quadrophenia and The Wall, you can probably tell that I've got nothing against the concept of the leitmotif. My problem with Final Fantasy XIII's leitmotif is that it recurs in almost every piece of music in the game. It's almost like you can't venture into a new location without hearing some variation on Serah's Theme, and it has the annoying property of beginning to grate on a person very quickly. Beyond those two themes, there really isn't anything memorable about the Final Fantasy XIII soundtrack. It's ambient and fits well, I suppose, given that it rarely detracts from the experience of playing the game. A point of contention among fans of the series is the decision to use Leona Lewis' song My Hands in the game. Having played it through, I wish to inform skeptics that the song is only heard once, over the game's final cut-scene, and while it's not the most congruous piece of music ever assigned to an unrelated media, it doesn't stand out in an ugly way. It's not as bad a fit as it's been made out to be, is what I'm saying. Not that I liked the song, mind.
In addition to the game's music, I'll use this spot to quickly talk about the game's voice acting and sound effects. The voice acting is a pretty mixed bag, although to be fair this is largely due to the quality of the game's script, which varies from pretty good to woefully clichéd and covers just about every point in beween. There are moments like those between Snow and Serah that come off really well in terms of their sincerity. On the other hand, there are moments where characters like Lightning and Hope play the melodrama card way too freely, making some scenes almost unwatchably cringe-worthy. It certainly doesn't live up to the high benchmark set by Final Fantasy XII's immaculate localization, but it's a passable effort from all involved (yes, even the voice actress who portrays Vanille). The game's sound-effects are pretty great all round, although fans of the Kingdom Hearts series of video games might notice that a lot of the game's menu sounds seem to have been ripped straight from the Square/Disney crossover action RPGs. It's not a big deal, but when a game was in development for four and a half years, you'd think we'd at least get some original 'ding's for menu navigation. On the whole, Final Fantasy XIII's audio is decidedly average, with its occasional highs being cancelled out by its occasional lows.
The World
Unfortunately, it's this very fact that ultimately works against the favour of the game world. Each of the environments is so intricately detailed and lovingly crafted that I often found myself wishing that I could return to previous locations in order to re-experience their beauty. However, backtracking isn't something that the game allows, save for right at the end when you're given the freedom to return to Gran Pulse as is your wont. Beyond the superficial aesthetic reasons for wanting to do so, though, there's very little incentive at all for wanting to return to previous locations. The game's linear nature means that a lot of what you can see on-screen isn't accessible, removing an incentive for exploration. This, coupled with the lack of side quests, means that even if it were possible to return to old locations, there would be no real reason to do so from a gameplay standpoint. More on all that later, though, in the relevant sections below. Final Fantasy XIII does a great job of creating a beautiful, unique and immersive game environment that you'll want to spend a lot of time in, but without the ability or a cause to stay there, it almost feels like all that effort was for very little pay-off.
The Story
Where it all falls apart for Final Fantasy XIII is the way in which this story is told. Most notably, there's the way in which the game's lore is handled. Previous Final Fantasies have done a great job of integrating story exposition into the games' scripts, working it into the dialogue of characters and often making parts of it available to only the most diligent of players in the form of secret events (Final Fantasy VII and Final Fantasy X are two great examples of this at work). Instead of taking this approach, Final Fantasy XIII decides to lump all of its exposition into a journal-like menu entry dubbed the Datalog. This means that in order to read up on the game's lore, it's necessary to actually remove yourself from the game world, completely shattering any sense of immersion that's built up. It also makes the game's story itself seem rather hollow, given that it leaves all the explanations to the Datalog. The other thing that really lets the game's story down is its script, which fluctuates wildly between 'ok' and 'downright terrible' throughout most of the game. There were a lot of moments where the awful script translation, coupled with the inconsistent quality of the voice acting, left me cringing at what I was watching. A lot of moments. In conclusion, Final Fantasy XIII has a pretty good story that suffers heavily through being told poorly. I found a lot to like beneath the surface, but in doing so I did a lot of unnecessary research through the Datalog that I really shouldn't have had to do.
The Characters
Let's start with the game's six playable characters. To say that they adhere rigidly to archetypes of the series would be putting it lightly. There's Lightning, the moody soldier who keeps to herself, much like Cloud and Squall before her. Snow is the self-proclaimed hero and all-round good guy, somewhat reminiscent of Zell, Tidus and even Zidane to some extent. Vanille is a chirpy, happy-go-lucky girl in the vein of Selphie and Rikku. Fang's a tough one to place, but with her down-to-earth, tough-girl attitude and Pulsian wisdom, she seems closest suited to the "elder" role previously adopted by characters like Cid Highwind and Auron. Hope is possibly the sole exception to this rule - a whiny, down-on-his-luck teenager who, in avoiding conforming to Final Fantasy archetypes, instead manages to go one step even further in the wrong direction by conforming to more generic JRPG archetypes. They all stick to their pre-determined natures consistently, and there is some character development (Lightning lightens up a little, Hope moans a little less), but ultimately there just wasn't anything unique enough about the cast to get me interested in their plight. I'm not saying I expected characters as great as Final Fantasy IX's existentialist black mage Vivi, or Final Fantasy XII's smooth-talking sky pirate Balthier, but a little originality would have been nice. The aforementioned exception, as some of you might have guessed from his omission, is Sazh. I was very worried about Sazh going in, given that the last time a Final Fantasy game featured a playable black character, he was essentially Mr. T, but I was proved very wrong and by the end of the game, despite not particularly caring for him, I did find him to be a pretty likeable guy compared to the rest of the cast. I think it's because he never came across as overly dramatic - he simply decided to grin and bear the situation, against insurmountable odds, and got on with things. When his emotions did come into play, it was always for valid reasons. I think that anybody who dismisses Sazh as a comic relief character does so at the risk of completely missing the game's best personality.
I don't have an awful lot to say about the game's supporting cast, which probably goes some way towards expressing how unmemorable most of them are. Bit-part characters like the other members of Snow's Team NORA, Hope's parents, and PSICOM members Jihl and Yaag all serve their purposes in terms of propelling the story forward without taking up too much time in the limelight. The NPC focus in Final Fantasy XIII is on Lightning's sister Serah, Sazh's son Dajh, and the leader of the Guardian Corps, Cid Raines. All three characters were tolerable, but they suffered from the same issue as the protagonists - they managed to evoke nothing but apathy from me. This fault even extends to the game's villain, the fal'Cie Barthandelus, who in spite of the power at his disposal, never really feels like a threat. Maybe it's because he takes so long to make himself known, but by the time he surfaced, even his plans for world destruction seemed uninteresting. Seeing as all the other fal'Cie don't possess any kind of personality, I don't even feel the need to address them in this section. For me, the cast of characters was one of Final Fantasy XIII's weakest components. Between the lack of originality displayed by the protagonists and the poor way in which their development was handled, I simply found myself unable to care about them at all. If I can walk away from almost sixty hours of gameplay without caring about the characters I've spent that time with, then something is pretty wrong.
The Exploration
The Combat
People have complained about only being able to control one character at a time. Personally, I didn't mind it in Final Fantasy XII, and I don't mind it here. Granting the player full control over all three combatants would mean slowing the whole battle system right down, which would kill the sense of urgency that makes battles so exhilirating. My one complaint related to this comes from the fact that every character has access to their own individual Eidolon, but only the party leader is able to use the Summon command in battle. Video_Game_King brought this up in his Final Fantasy XIII blog, and pointed out that there are two unused shoulder buttons on the controller during battle that could very easily have been used to cycle player control between the three party members. It also would have really helped to make early-fight preparations a little bit faster - being able to switch to Hope at the start of a battle to cast all the relevant buffs before switching back to Lightning to focus on dealing damage would have made a few boss battles a lot easier. Final Fantasy XII boasted this feature, so why Final Fantasy XIII doesn't is beyond me. This complaint aside, though, I really can't find much fault with the Final Fantasy XIII battle system. It's a brave and exciting attempt to breathe new life into old mechanics, and it's arguably the most successful attempt to do so since way back when Final Fantasy IV first introduced us all to the Active Time Battle system in 1991.
The Statistical Stuff
My complaint with the statistical side of Final Fantasy XIII comes in the form of the Crystarium levelling system. Having heard the comparisons to Final Fantasy X's Sphere Grid and (to a lesser extent) Final Fantasy XII's Licence Board, I was quite excited to see for myself how character development was going to be handled. This excitement turned quite rapidly to disappointment as I realised that the Crystarium was actually as linear as the game's environments, with set paths and set nodes for each character. This meant I had only one way to develop each character in each role, giving me no room to experiment with character development whatsoever. Given the streamlined statistical aspect of the game, this also means that a lot of Crystarium roles seem pretty much identical and it's difficult to know which roles offer the best statistical pay-off. With the pre-defined roles turning out to be as important in combat as they are, I suppose flexibility was never really going to be a viable option, but in that case, why tout the Crystarium as a flexible character development tool? I don't think the Crystarium would have disappointed me had I not had expectations for it, but it was precisely the way the developers talked about the Crystarium that got me hyped up for it. In conclusion, the cutting down of the statistical aspect is fine by me, especially if it makes the franchise more accessible to newcomers, but the rigidity of the Crystarium left me feeling disappointed and lied to by the developers.
The Side Quests
The Verdict
With its prolonged development cycle and the immense level of hype surrounding its release, Final Fantasy XIII was always going to leave some kind of lasting legacy. For me personally, it will be remembered as an aesthetically magnificent adventure through an incredible world, telling a compelling story. Admittedly, it doesn't do the best job of telling that story, and its poor script-writing and voice acting often left me feeling apathetic towards the events and the characters. In terms of its gameplay, its strongest suit is by far its overhauled combat system and its attempts to streamline character development. It falls short of the mark with regards to exploration and side quests, simply because it doesn't offer much to do outside of running and fighting. It's a real shame, because Cocoon and Pulse are worlds that I would have loved to spend more time in, but the game gives me no real incentive to do so. It's not the best Final Fantasy ever made, but nor is it by any means the worst. If anything, it's an interesting experiment - a development team's tentative first step into the current generation, and hopefully one that they can learn from with a view to making bigger strides in the near future. With Final Fantasy XIV announced as the series' second foray into the MMORPG genre, I'll be holding out for news on Final Fantasy XV, as and when it comes, and hoping that Square Enix play to their strengths in the development of the next title in one of my favourite game franchises of all time.Whoa. Long blog. No word of a lie, this thing is genuinely longer than any single essay I've written since I started University almost two years ago. Then again, it has taken me well over a week to work my way from the top of this page to the bottom. I guess at this stage, all that's left for me to do is apologise about the wall of text above (as far as walls of text go, this must be the Great Wall-Of-Text Of China), and leave you all with some closing thoughts. I'm currently playing Red Dead Redemption, which in itself has proven to be a factor in this blog's incredibly late arrival. I've already managed to sink nearly thirty hours into it over the space of about two weeks, so I think it's pretty safe to say that I'm absolutely hooked. I've just unlocked the second landmass, Nuevo Paraiso, so I'm currently exploring the new territory and getting the lay of the land before I get stuck back into more story missions and stranger-helping. It's distracted me almost completely from Enduring Final Fantasy VII, but you have my word that a new episode of that will be coming before the month is out. Other than that, I really don't think there's much else to say. Probably just as well, because I think I've said more than enough. I hope you're all well, and hope to see you around Giant Bomb a little more over the coming summer months.
Dan
---
Currently playing - Red Dead Redemption (X360)