Giveaway Mixup: Thoughts?

Hey, 
 
I'm a really disappointed guy. 
 
Without going into specifics in this blog (because I don't feel like making a bad situation worse), I'd like to pose a situation to all the Giant Bombs in the audience tonight, and ask what they think the outcome should be. 
 
I entered a contest being held by a software company, of whose software I already enthusiastically use.  Their software is free, but they have paid enhancements.  The paid licenses aren't very cheap; I spent $400 on such a license last year.  They were giving away a license valued at $1,500 in this giveaway. 
 
I got excited yesterday when I saw that I'd won the contest!  And then I noticed that there had to be a mistake of some sort.  To enter the contest, you had to say what you planned to do with their software in 2011.  The plans they said I had weren't my plans at all, but they were attributed to my name.  The company contacted me to congratulate me and ask for my e-mail response so they could set me up with the license. 
 
I, being a dope, played the game of honesty.  I told them that I didn't know whether the contest was a random drawing or based on the merits of people's plans, but the winning idea was not matched to the winning name.