Something went wrong. Try again later
    Follow

    Turn-Based

    Concept »

    Turn-based games divide game actions into distinct parts, called turns. This gives the player time to strategically choose actions as the battle or events unfold.

    Regarding turn-based combat

    Avatar image for mayu_zane
    Mayu_Zane

    710

    Forum Posts

    1285

    Wiki Points

    0

    Followers

    Reviews: 1

    User Lists: 8

    Edited By Mayu_Zane

     I've been thinking a bit about the turn-based combat systems a lot of RPGs have. Some would have turns decided by how agile the characters are, others by using a time-gauge system or an 'Action Points' bar. Regardless of how it's set up though, it always seemed jarring to me for everyone to just stand still while one person did one thing.

    I had an idea about how to add a bit more excitement to the combat: Time-freeze. Allow me to elaborate.

    Let's say you have a party of three. The main character is a mage, with a long-range bow-using companion way in the back and up in front we have a tough bruiser. The enemy is three Evil Refrigerators.

    The tough bruiser has the fastest reflexes and so begins first. Time suddenly freezes; no breathing animation, no movement at all while the action menu is up. The player chooses 'Attack Evil Fridge 1', and the combat animation immediately follows. However, instead of Tough Bruiser just hitting Fridge 1 and then returning to pre-combat position, the fight continues until the Mage finally manages to pull out the big and heavy spellbook from the bag. Time freezes once the book is finally open; the player now selects 'Lame Tier Fire Spell' and the Mage casts the spell.

    However, before the Mage could finish saying all the words for the spell, Fridge 2 has made a move. Before the Fridge reaches the Mage, time freezes again; it's the bow-users turn.

    At this point, the Bow-user can attack any of the Evil Refrigerators, but the player can issue a special command: Rescue. This is basically an attack that delivers enough damage to distract the enemy from a weak ally, but also risks the rest of the enemy team to focus only on the rescuer.

    The bow-user chooses to Rescue the mage from a cold death, and two Refrigerators have shifted attention to the bow-user. Now the Mage can return to finishing the original action (Cast Lame Tier Fire Spell).

    I prefer the idea of a battle that's constantly continuing, instead of everyone standing around and just waiting for their turn. I like the idea that it would look like your commands are actually the split-second decisions of the in-game characters.

    Apologies if something like this has been used before. I don't have much time for a lot of RPGs and I haven't seen something like this ever implemented in a game. However, if it has been attempted I'd like to have a look myself. 

    Avatar image for mayu_zane
    Mayu_Zane

    710

    Forum Posts

    1285

    Wiki Points

    0

    Followers

    Reviews: 1

    User Lists: 8

    #1  Edited By Mayu_Zane

     I've been thinking a bit about the turn-based combat systems a lot of RPGs have. Some would have turns decided by how agile the characters are, others by using a time-gauge system or an 'Action Points' bar. Regardless of how it's set up though, it always seemed jarring to me for everyone to just stand still while one person did one thing.

    I had an idea about how to add a bit more excitement to the combat: Time-freeze. Allow me to elaborate.

    Let's say you have a party of three. The main character is a mage, with a long-range bow-using companion way in the back and up in front we have a tough bruiser. The enemy is three Evil Refrigerators.

    The tough bruiser has the fastest reflexes and so begins first. Time suddenly freezes; no breathing animation, no movement at all while the action menu is up. The player chooses 'Attack Evil Fridge 1', and the combat animation immediately follows. However, instead of Tough Bruiser just hitting Fridge 1 and then returning to pre-combat position, the fight continues until the Mage finally manages to pull out the big and heavy spellbook from the bag. Time freezes once the book is finally open; the player now selects 'Lame Tier Fire Spell' and the Mage casts the spell.

    However, before the Mage could finish saying all the words for the spell, Fridge 2 has made a move. Before the Fridge reaches the Mage, time freezes again; it's the bow-users turn.

    At this point, the Bow-user can attack any of the Evil Refrigerators, but the player can issue a special command: Rescue. This is basically an attack that delivers enough damage to distract the enemy from a weak ally, but also risks the rest of the enemy team to focus only on the rescuer.

    The bow-user chooses to Rescue the mage from a cold death, and two Refrigerators have shifted attention to the bow-user. Now the Mage can return to finishing the original action (Cast Lame Tier Fire Spell).

    I prefer the idea of a battle that's constantly continuing, instead of everyone standing around and just waiting for their turn. I like the idea that it would look like your commands are actually the split-second decisions of the in-game characters.

    Apologies if something like this has been used before. I don't have much time for a lot of RPGs and I haven't seen something like this ever implemented in a game. However, if it has been attempted I'd like to have a look myself. 

    Avatar image for sanryd
    Sanryd

    1443

    Forum Posts

    2330

    Wiki Points

    0

    Followers

    Reviews: 1

    User Lists: 3

    #2  Edited By Sanryd

    I could have misunderstood the point of your post entirely, but are you saying that you would just like the waiting that occurs between turns in an RPG to be justified in some meaningful way? If not, the game that sticks out in my mind that plays exactly how you describe is FFXII. There may be others but that's what came to mind first.

    Avatar image for coombs
    Coombs

    3509

    Forum Posts

    587

    Wiki Points

    0

    Followers

    Reviews: 1

    User Lists: 5

    #3  Edited By Coombs

    I honestly prefer the old straight up turn based combat 
    ie: FFVI, Chrono Trigger, Suikoden, ect, ect....

    Avatar image for animateria
    animateria

    3341

    Forum Posts

    0

    Wiki Points

    0

    Followers

    Reviews: 0

    User Lists: 4

    #4  Edited By animateria

    Sounds like Grandia... You can actually interrupt enemy attacks during their 'charge' phase. Sames goes for them against your attacks.
     
    A simple attack doesn't take much charge, but a large spell requires a long charge time to cast and can be interrupted.
     
    Oh, and Resonance of Fate does a similar thing.

    Avatar image for themasterds
    TheMasterDS

    3018

    Forum Posts

    7716

    Wiki Points

    0

    Followers

    Reviews: 1

    User Lists: 31

    #5  Edited By TheMasterDS

    I like the model where each dude gets one turn per turn regardless of the time it takes to navigate menus. 

    Avatar image for animateria
    animateria

    3341

    Forum Posts

    0

    Wiki Points

    0

    Followers

    Reviews: 0

    User Lists: 4

    #6  Edited By animateria
    @TheMasterDS: 
     
    In his model the menu stuff is still frozen.
    Avatar image for themasterds
    TheMasterDS

    3018

    Forum Posts

    7716

    Wiki Points

    0

    Followers

    Reviews: 1

    User Lists: 31

    #7  Edited By TheMasterDS
    @animateria: Right, of course. I hadn't read it very closely and had thought the idea was that how much the action would be slowed down would be based on how smart the party member was. 
     
    I guess a few of the ideas could work if the ideas were the battles would be shorter but more action pact. If you have to cast a spell of RPG to take down a helicopter enemy 3 times and you have to distract the enemy each time to get off the spell, that could be very bad. As for the basic idea, it sorta sounds like a little Bioware RPG mixed into the traditional RPG, but then I don't see that improving gameplay at all honestly. Unless it was all contextual, like say a battle goes like this. 
     
    1. You choose targets for all dudes using and start them up. 
     
    2. Time pauses as one enemy looks like he draws a gun on one of your charging dudes. How long it takes to pause is based on a reflex stat. You can now choose to revise your action, by say, dodging. Basically the decisions you make at this point will be focused on reducing risk or reducing reward.
     
    3. After you successfully attack or whatever you choose what to do next. Whether to back up, whether to give him more, that sort of thing. 
     
    The presumption should be that in this system an attack may easily put down an enemy, and a hit may do 1/3 of your health easy. It should be fast and visceral. 
    Avatar image for mayu_zane
    Mayu_Zane

    710

    Forum Posts

    1285

    Wiki Points

    0

    Followers

    Reviews: 1

    User Lists: 8

    #8  Edited By Mayu_Zane
    @tdk08: Yeah, I'd like some justification to the waiting. Everyone is slightly faster or slower than everyone else due to their own reflex/response time, or possibly because their weapons and attacks take time to set up. In the time to say a spell, a guy could easily throw something at you. For gun-users, the 'wait-time' is actually the character reloading while moving around the field to dodge attacks.
    Avatar image for video_game_king
    Video_Game_King

    36563

    Forum Posts

    59080

    Wiki Points

    0

    Followers

    Reviews: 54

    User Lists: 14

    #9  Edited By Video_Game_King
    @Coombs said:
    " I honestly prefer the old straight up turn based combat  ie: FFVI, Chrono Trigger, Suikoden, ect, ect.... "
    Um, you mean Active Time Battle? And on the subject of turn based combat, it's not meant to represent reality; it's a way of condensing cinematic qualities into gameplay.
    Avatar image for cornman89
    Cornman89

    1600

    Forum Posts

    0

    Wiki Points

    0

    Followers

    Reviews: 1

    User Lists: 0

    #10  Edited By Cornman89

    Yeah, you need to get your hands on some hot Grandia action. Far as I'm concerned, that's the perfect turn-based combat system, and a lot of the ideas you're describing can be found in those games, too.

    This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.