I'm going to preface this by saying I was about 20 years too old for Emo. If it had hit while I was in high school, I may have gone way down that rabbit hole. That said, I enjoyed (and still enjoy) emo music quite a bit, and that was my entry point for AFI. I think there is little question that this is one of the top two or three albums in the entire genre, if not from an artistic standpoint than from pure radio play and recognition. FYI, Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge is also high on my playlist, but MCR isn't nearly the band that AFI is.
I have a lot of respect for the longevity of AFI. They went from being a solid punk band to a preeminent emo band and then to a solid adult alternative rock band. It does seem like it was really a right place, right time situation for the band, as you can hear the slight changes in their sound over the course of their discography which kind of . (I know that emo didn't just suddenly start up in the 2000s, but I'm generally talking mainstream). Sing The Sorrow and Crash Love are kind of the bookends of this mainstream emo trilogy, with Decemberunderground being the dark middle chapter.
I think it is a pretty solid album top to bottom, but Love Like Winter was the song that really got me into the band in the first place. Endlessly, She Said, The Interview, and 37mm are probably my other favorites, but again, not really a weak track on the album. Maybe Miss Murder is lower on the list for me.
I saw the band live in 2019, opening for High Flying Birds and Smashing Pumpkins, and I had very mixed feelings about it. They put on a great, though short, set. But I personally would have replaced six of the eight songs they played. That said, don't sleep on their newer albums. I haven't listened to them all yet, but the 2017 album is very good.
Log in to comment