rafoXxX

And Shivering Isles is also up there on rich setting, characters and lore, I'd say.

Wow. Just a while ago I was remembering how much I enjoyed and also hated this game. Then I see this... Cue Twilight Zone theme...
 
I didn't know Bethesda owned Arkane. Does this mean we'll get Dark Messiah of Might & Magic style swordplay in TES: Skyrim perhaps? Hmmm.

Akavir. Exotic. Chance for new content, like new races for example (aren´t akavirians some sort of oriental dragon like people?).
 
That or an MMO encompassing all of Tamriel. An instanced MMO kinda like Guild Wars would be acceptable. An MMO like WoW not. No. Uh-uh. 
 
Summerset Isles, Skyrim, or any other specific province only would just outright suck, even thought I´d play the hell out of it anyway.

Cool topic, bro...
Too bad it´s so empty.
 
I recently restarted Oblivion ´coz I never played Shivering Isles nor did any of the Dark Brotherhood or Thief Guild quests. My custom class is Morag Tong.
Dark elf, of course.

No thank you?
 
YES thank you!!!
 
Why in the six hundred and sixty six hells would anyone not want this?
 
Might suck, sure. But what if it doesn't?...

The LEFT4DEADs are making brain hurt...

You're right about the soundtrack, of course. I shouldn't have compared it to the SotN OST. I also like other orchestrated, or "ambient", remixes. 
But then I did say "could be", meaning I'd have absolutely no complaints if this actually was used for a CV3 soundtrack... I mean, the songs are all there, recognizable, and spot on, whether you like 'em metal or not. And they're not all metal... only 80%... ;P
 
About quests: To be clear, I did say "side" quests, so yeah, the quest system shouldn't be a requirement. However, obtaining those darn crystals, or getting that dude to power up your whip for blazing, and stuff like that I think should come with some kind of trade-off like for example a minimum level requirement or, I dunno, having a certain Dracula's Piece on you. After all, these dudes practically act as "metroidvania keys", in that they basically open up new areas.
 
Yes, definately a mana bar for subweapons. I meant that, yes, totally. Say, like in Portrait of Ruin?
 

@kevinski

Dying in Water - Oh, I dunno. I'm of the belief that some Belmonts just can't swim. :P

@kevinski

Dumb Stuff Done Better - I agree to an extent, although I think that it'd be nice to have a lot of truly hidden, truly obscure triggers to special events. Sometimes, the Internet really just kills a lot of the intrigue here.

@kevinski

Richter-esque Game Play - I disagree. It shouldn't be so fast-paced. Richter was completely insane in terms of play style. As much as I love playing as Richter, I don't see someone in Simon's condition handling things at Richter's pace.

@kevinski

Day/Night Cycles - I'd like to see real-time day/night cycles in a Simon's Quest remake, with the time being IP-based to force players to actually play the game at certain times (rather than simply waiting for a period of time to pass) for certain quests. I kinda miss the days of interesting date- and time-based events in games, and I also think that basing it on any sort of internal clock within the game kills some of the charm and intrigue of said events. There would, of course, be perks to encourage players to play at different times of day in addition to the time-specific quests.  (Note: This would, ideally, be a downloadable game, so having an Internet connection should be required.)

God-friggin-dammit!!! Fuck the upcoming Lords of Shadow! Why? 'Coz it ain't a 2D side-scroller. Simple as that. Castlevania just does not work as a God of War clone. I mean, it works, but it's not Castlevania in my book. Just ends up bein' another God of War clone.
It might be good, story-wise, and that's the part that frustrates me the most. Wouldn't it be awesome to have this kind of gritty "seriousness" and fleshed out storytelling specifically in a remake of Simon's Quest or Dracula's Curse? I mean, both those games were already pretty gritty and "serious", just that they were filled with "bad translation disease", not to mention lack of text space.

So, here's an idea I've had ALL MY FUCKING LIFE:
(but first a bit of backstory)
Ever since I played Simon's Quest back in 1989 (this being the very first Castlevania game I'd ever played) I've been hooked on Castlevania games. I loved Simon's Quest. I really did. I thought it was an epic, sinister adventure. At the time, there were no walkthroughs or anything, so either you figured things out by word of mouth or NINTENDO POWER. Although even with the latter you'd only get a few hints. I was lucky enough to have a random kid randomly mention in a random conversation the "kneeling at Deborah Cliff" bit. Lucky break. But really, it was all about exploration and riddle-solving. Granted the riddles were bad translations, borderline "engrish", but some actually did help me. So, I explored... Talked to everyone, hit every single block in every single screen with holy water flasks, jumped into every wall in case it were invisible... This rocked! I couldn't stop thinking about Simon's Quest.
And at the time I never understood why the 1st Castlevania was such a big deal. I thought it was boring. Just a regular old "hold right, fight boss, hold right some more" platformer. Simon's Quest was a whole big huge adventure that took place in a world big enough to explore and let the imagination soar, and that took me months to figure out and complete! 
Then along came Castlevania III, and I understood.
At first I was dissapoiinted that this was just another "hold right till end", but little by little as I played I started to realize I was playing a friggin' AWESOME game! The music... The branching paths... The other characters... Even the graphics, the level variations, the map... It slowly started to sink in that this was probably what Castlevania should be, now and forever. 
And then much later I played SOTN. What can I say?... Mind = BLOWN. It was non-linear! Had an actual inventory! The graphics! The music! This was like Simon's Quest but a million times better!
I loved SOTN. A lot.
But you know what? All the while, as I played an replayed SOTN, I kept thinking: "Man, it'd just be death-dealingly-AWESOME if they remade Simon's Quest with SOTN's production quality..."
 
Now, Konami's gone and remade a few Castlevania games quite a few times. The original Castlevania was remade so many times I just end up ignoring them all. Recently they remade Rondo of Blood. That game did not need a remake. It did not. The original already kicked ass. Sure, it sold like crazy, and yeah, it being finally ported over was nice, but it did not need to be remade.
 
So (finally) my eternal, wishful, probably not original, idea is this:
 
Why oh why won't Konami remake Simon's Quest and Dracula's Curse, Bionic Commando Rearmed style, goddammit?!?! Simon's Quest could really be epic! It could be "the next step" from  the "metroidvanias", way larger in scale! It would have a whole semi-open world to explore, not just a castle. Here's a list of features I think would make this an instant classic and just headplodingly good:
 

Castlevania Chronicles: Simon's Quest

• Side-quests! Give those townspeople a purpose! You want someone to sell you their laurels? Well, first you gotta do them a little favor. Already, this could lead to a way more fleshed-out game! The dudes that trade those damn crystals... make 'em be "main quest" related. They won't trade unless you do whatever they ask of you first.

• A well-made day/night cycle that would actually influence not only enemies' strength but also be related to quests and events. Imagine some dude asked you to pick an herb for them that only grows at night in the Veros Woods. Or maybe one of the mansions only appears at dawn or dusk. There would of course be a visual way of telling what time of day it is, whether by the ambient lighting itself, or by some small, non-intrusive hud element . In towns, you would see people going into their homes and such as night approaches.
• Reintegrate the classic subweapons as subweapons are supposed to be used. Finding some of them could well be quest related.
  
• The currency would of course not be hearts, but gold, such as it's been in all metroidvanias since SOTN. Hearts could still play a role, such as ammo counters/mana recharge for subweapons, why not...
• Those creepy guys in cloaks that hide behind floors or walls in houses, or give you the oak stakes in the mansions, or like the guy that gives you the flame whip, they could be part of a secret, shady sect of Belmont followers that help when and however they can, often from "behind enemy lines" even. They might've been formed after Trevor's adventures.
  
• In mansions, before obtaining a Dracula's piece, there'd be obligatory boss fights. This of course instead of like in the original where for example you could just walk on by Death itself, get your Dracula's piece, and waltz back out as if on a guided tour.
  
• A map system, of course. It'd be cool to have a reference to the name of the area you're in, maybe in the sub-screen. Finally you'd know if you were in Veros Woods, Camilla's Cemetery, or Jam Wasteland.
• Dumb stuff would be done better. The crystals that open new areas would have an explanation, like they summon the help of God or someshit. So for example you kneel (pray?) on that god damn Deborah's Cliff holding the red crystal, and a powerful gust of wind lifts you up to it's top, instead of a tornado warping you to another location.
  
• You would not die in water. At the most, there could be poisonous ponds/lakes that damage or poison you if fallen in.
  

• Graphics related: SOTN style graphics would be fine, I think. For the outdoor areas where there were "ladders" in the original, instead there could simply be side paths represented graphically. There could be signposts in these crossroads indicating what leads where. But then you could also just check the map. Of course different areas would have different artistic design, so for ex. the Aljiba Woods and the Veros Woods would not look like the same cookie-cutter woods.
• Gameplay related: Like SOTN when controlling Richter. Not much more to say than that.
  

• Story related: Finally Simon, the original Belmont (I don't mean timeline-wise), could have his epic, tragic story told with full detail. He was cursed as Drac died, so he could be sort of a tortured soul as he knows this quest will not end well for him, whether he undoes the curse or not. Even if there were different endings, I think it'd be cool to have Simon die either way, so as to feel some "emotional attatchment" to this character you play as throughout the game. If not, he'd be just "another Belmont". Also 'twould be cool if he was all haggard and worn. And with a beard.
• The final in Dracula's castle would of course NOT BE FRICKIN' EMPTY, and Dracula himself would not be a total pushover. Actually, Drac's castle could be a mini-level like the size of one of the Portrait of Ruin areas.

Castlevania Chronicles: Dracula's Curse

• Again, graphics and gameplay updated to be SOTN-like. The characters' sprites were already there, even!
  
• The partner system could very well be much like it is in Portrait of Ruin. Could even allow for a co-op option maybe?
• The partner's gameplay mechanics themselves could very well be improved upon. Grant's wall hugging made easier, Sypha's magic made a wee bit more "complex", like being able to choose what spell to use instead of that being determined by whatever spell drops from candles, and Alucard's cape-fireball attack would be a wee bit more damaging (but not much).
  
• Map system would also allow for Stage Select, much as in Rondo of Blood.
• Frickin' KICKASS updated soundtrack.

I'm in.

Every Extend Extra!