So, news! Upcoming game Dead or Alive: Dimensions for the 3DS currently doesn't have a place on Nordic distributor Bergsalas website. How come, you might ask?
Everything started with a thread on Swedish forum "Flashback", which is famous for being the biggest place to discuss EVERYTHING. A user started a thread saying that he would try to convict the company for selling a game figuring child pornography to test a newly installed law. Last year, the same law got a Swedish manga translator convicted for the same crime. It's currently being tested in the highest instance of the Swedish courts. According to this new law; any picture depicting a person under 18 years of age, even if it's animated or a drawing, is child pornography.
Back to the actual case about this game. Bergsala's Patrik Johansson told Swedish website Gamereactor that "Nintendo of Europe has due to various reasons decided not to distribute the game in Sweden. They do not want to go into details, but state it's due to several resons. Thus, unfortunately I cannot declare Nintendo's reasoning regarding the matter."
The theory spreading around is that the games characters Kasumi, Kokoro and Ayane who are all under 18 years old can be seen in revealing outfits. This might be further used in the "Figure Mode" (where you apparently can take photos of the girls) and thus, CHILD PORNOGRAPHY is the thing you're looking into if you're buying DOA: Dimensions in Sweden.
One Swedish retailer is however still going to sell this game.
So, what do you think? Isn't this kinda of a stretch for the industry? I'm a huge fan of manga and anime, and I've always liked the Dead or Alive games somewhat, even if they include a kinda of a pervy side.
Dead or Alive: Dimensions
Game » consists of 4 releases. Released May 24, 2011
Dead or Alive: Dimensions retells the story of the Dead or Alive saga, adding new playable characters and more features in this handheld debut of the Dead or Alive fighting game franchise.
On the ban-wagon: Dead or Alive: Dimensions no go in Sweden
What? Even the volleyball games, which are even marketed as glorified fapping tools shouldn't be classified as that. Creepy and voyueristic? Yes. Child Porn? No.
Get the localizers to go in to the bio, update all the info for the girls to 18 - problem solved. What are they going to argue - I know this totally fictional cartoon is meant ot be under 18 and I will call her to the stand to present her fictional birth certificate ... no wait.
I forgot to include that the law also says that any character that is "in sexually inciting situations" who may look underage also is classified as child pornography.What? Even the volleyball games, which are even marketed as glorified fapping tools shouldn't be classified as that. Creepy and voyueristic? Yes. Child Porn? No.
But they don't look that young. Child pornography is not seeing a hot 17 year old in a bikini. Child pornography is graphic pics of young, pre-pubescent children. Look at movies like American Pie, where all the characters are all suppose to be in high school. Is this movie also child pornography? What a stupid law.
Get the localizers to go in to the bio, update all the info for the girls to 18 - problem solved. What are they going to argue - I know this totally fictional cartoon is meant ot be under 18 and I will call her to the stand to present her fictional birth certificate ... no wait.Let's just hope its not too late.
Now does the law prohibit the existence of such imagery within the country or simply the commercial enterprise dealing with such imagery? The law is stupid either way but ban on selling a product and a ban on the product itself are two different things.
Man and I thought Sweden was cool. Oh wait, it's just as shitty as any other country with its own problems and lapses of logic. I tell you man, any sociology department makes it seems like Sweden is this socially conscious mecca where infinite money seems to pour out of a hole to feed the hungry and care for the sick. Luckily I know better than to just take a country at face value and know it for all its good and bad qualities. This is one where Sweden's thinks it's being progressive when it's just being an idiot.
So what's next, banning the internet? Because let me tell ya there's a lot of naked cartoon pussy on the internet and this law might make illegal like half of them.
The Flashback member that reported the game got the following response from the police:
Farbror Blå said:
So the game was not banned. Nintendo could totally have released it and everything would've been fine. They just chose not to, to be on the safe side."I've looked at everything you've linked, but can't find any child pornography...? It's not enough to write that someone's 17 years old, and besides, the image in itself is not pornographic."
Now does the law prohibit the existence of such imagery within the country or simply the commercial enterprise dealing with such imagery?As I understand, the existence.
@Tuffgong said:
it seems like Sweden is this socially conscious mecca where infinite money seems to pour out of a hole to feed the hungry and care for the sick.Well, that not entirely true nowadays (certainly not when youngsters like me have a hard time finding a job, since the job market is like the worst thing ever) even if it was a signum of Sweden once.
@Tuffgong said:
So what's next, banning the internet?If we should be honest, there has been laws that wanted this to happen more or less in Sweden, making the internet harder to access and so on.
@Icemael said:
So the game was not banned. Nintendo could totally have released it and everything would've been fine. They just chose not to, to be on the safe side.That's were the problem is however. This sudden moral of everything with cute, supposedly little, girls being turned into child pornography. I can't wait to get someone home to me and start rambling of how a bad person I am because of my Miku figurine at home, or something like that. If this law becomes something "normal" in peoples eyes, the whole interest of east asian culture will probably fade away, since their culture not always depict how young or old a person is in media.
@KaosAngel: 16 here, I'd forgotten how low some countries go before checking wikipedia just now. Not sure what to think.
Looks like the game has had it's classification revoked.. in which country you ask? Take a wild guess..
http://www.kotaku.com.au/2011/06/dead-or-alive-dimensions-has-its-classification-revoked/comment-page-2/#comments
Please Log In to post.
This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:
Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.Comment and Save
Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.
Log in to comment