Really disappointing. The movie felt like something that should happen in between Star Wars movies.
One big problem I had is that Johnson didn't feel the need to answer any of our questions. Whose Snoke? Doesn't matter, he's dead. Will Rey or Kylo switch sides? No. Will Luke train Rey? Nope. Rey's parentage was made out to be a big deal, so does it matter to the plot? Nope, they could have just established her parents were nobodies right off the bat and nothing changes.
A lot of the plot felt unsatisfying. The Rey training scenes, if you can call them that, felt pointless as we didn't see any character growth from her. The dark-side tempting made sense in Empire, since you know Luke can end up like his father. If Rey's parents are nobodies and she never actually seems tempted to the dark side outside of some throw-away lines by Kylo, the recreation of those scenes don't provide any plot value. Snoke basically admitting to manipulating Kylo and Rey felt silly too. The Emperor wanted to turn Luke, and Snoke just wants to kill Rey and Luke (for some unknown reason). Lame.
There's plenty of other nit-picky stuff, but there just feels like so much that it brings the whole movie down. The Finn/Rose plot seemed to only serve the purpose of getting most of the rebellion, including Luke, killed. Why wouldn't (Holdo, I think?) have just told Poe and everyone else that they planned on fleeing to the planet that had a base that they'd been looking for in the first place? Why did they care about fuel when they were a few hours at normal speed away from where they were headed? Why didn't the Falcon just fly back and blow up Kylo's command ship before his confrontation with Luke? They saw the Rebel base getting its butt kicked, so why wouldn't they go back to help them? How did Finn and Rose not at least get captured when they crashed right at the foot of the AT-AT's? The light-speeding ships into other ships was cool, but why wasn't the plan to do that at the start?
Plenty of other problems, like Luke's character as a whole, pacing issues, pointless characters (I cant believe they treated Phasma the same way in this after how people felt after TFA), etc. Honestly, I left it feeling like I had just watched the worse Star Wars movie. Even the Prequels, for all their faults, did a ton of world building. This one just felt... boring.
Log in to comment