2018 Game of the Year
By GameSmashing 0 Comments
Video version of my full awards:
Part 1 Where I give out awards while teaching you how to make donuts, a juicy lucy, and minty steak.
Part 2 after my phone overheated.
Thoughts on every game:
The Awesome Adventures of Captain Spirit- Even though it’s sort of a half demo for Life is Strange 2, it still stands as it’s own work. The character of Chris is so relatable because he is sort of an everyday kid with an overactive imagination. But on a personal level, I connected with this character because of his relationship with his dad. In short, as an only child with an alcoholic dad, there were many times I wish I could boil alcohol away using my mind powers before realizing it’s not possible. Even beyond that, the ostensibly simple task of making macaroni and cheese takes on an entirely new context when you spend the whole time walking on eggshells because you’re afraid of what would happen to Chris if you, as a player, were to make a mistake. It’s storytelling moments like this that made me choose it as the best story over even the likes of Red Dead Redemption 2 and God of War. I will always choose stories that use the nature of games to tell their stories over dozens of hours of cutscenes and dialog while walking to the next objective any day of the week, and The Awesome Adventures of Captain Spirit uses the medium to get some rather poignant themes across over the course of its 3 or so hour run time. Highly recommend if only to draw weird stuff in the snow outside.
Detroit: Become Human- If you were able to tolerate my cooking show long enough to get to the most disappointing category, you heard my short take on this game. If you frequent Giant Bomb Dot Com, you’ve heard Alex Navarro mercilessly tear this game apart multiple times. Long story short, this game is bad because it thinks it’s actually doing something unique or good by using Androids as a metaphor for racism. THERE IS A MOMENT WHERE ANDROIDS ARE LITERALLY STANDING IN THE BACK OF A BUS… But in spite of that, there was a stretch where I was actually enjoying it for some reason. Causing a war between androids and humans was sort of fun in a way. Then it’s revealed that Alice, the little girl that Kara saves, is actually and Android. I spent the rest of the game trying to get all these characters killed. Yes, I detonated the dirty bomb at the end of this game because this game is bad. Recommended to people who didn’t already know that Detroit apparently shares a border with Canada.
Donut County- As a huge Katamari Damacy fan, I was immediately hooked by the concept of Donut County. You control a hole in the ground, and you move the hole around to make things fall into your hole, making your hole bigger, so you can put bigger things in your hole (there is almost no way to describe this game without it being euphemistic). Beyond that, BK is one of my favorite characters of the year, the writing is surprisingly good, it has the best music of the year, and at the end of the day, gave me 2 of the most entertaining hours of the year. In a year where most games seemed to make me want to finish them just to be done with it, this game left me wanting more. It’s the one game I keep coming back to just to experience each fantastic element of it time and time again. Highest Recommendation Possible if you like Katamari, dope soundtracks, and raccoon gentrification.
Fallout 76- There is an alternate universe where a version of me who hated the RPG elements of Fallout 3 and New Vegas and was absolutly stoked to hear about a Fallout game that didn’t have any of the talky-talk, moral quandary stuff. I went into this game knowing what a unparalleled disaster it was in every possible way, and I still feel underwhelmed. If it wasn’t a hot mess, there is definitely an audience for this type of game, even within the Fallout community. But it is devoid of literally every single thing that would put Fallout: New Vegas is in my top 10 of all time. Recommended if you like singing along to The Beach Boys while being aggressively apathetic about West Virginia.
Far Cry 5- As interesting as its initial premise was, Far Cry 5’s complete refusal to engage with the topics it brings up was kind of lame. The whole cult drugging the water supply of Hope County felt like a cop-out in every conceivable way. If you want to write generic and uninteresting stories, this game is a decent road map. Throw in a repetitive and boring structure to the game and you have a not particularly great game. Although running through an enemy outpost with a bear and a cougar was some of the most fun I had all year. Recommended as long as you ignore all the stuff the game makes you do and make your animal friends do all the murdering in your place so you can still stick to your pacifist role play.
God of War- God of War is one of my favorite franchises in all of gaming. At first, I was both super excited and apprehensive about the new direction this reboot was taking the series. Over the course of the game, I enjoyed the more restrained nature of this game and the evolving relationship between Kratos and Atreus was one of the more interesting aspects of a game all year. But the more I played the less I liked actually playing it. The combat is okay, but I feel this game would have been better if they had gone all the way in the “SoulsBourne” direction. Hearing the way people talk about this game makes me wish someone had told me to play it like a Fallout game, where you do a bunch of side stuff, then play the main story stuff as far as you need to unlock more side stuff. Recommended if you like the word “Boy” or just want to see Kratos’s toxic masculinity bullshit get shut down by a child.
Hitman 2- What’s to say about this game beyond saying it’s more of the Hitman 2016 reboot. That reboot is in my top 5 games of this generation and all this game needed to be was more of that. It definitely is, but there are also some additions and changes in this sequel that make it not only more of the reboot, it’s a better version of the reboot. Throw in the fact that you can get all of the maps from that first season in this second season, you have a recipe for another one of the best games of the generation. It also has some of the most ridiculous Easter eggs of any game this year. Recommended if you like fun murder simulators or just want to turn half the population of Whittleton Creek into Sideshow Bob.
Into the breach- Much like Undertale in 2015, this is s game that everyone I follow on social media blew up about so I had to at least try it out. When I played, I was drawn in by it being more of a puzzle game than a Mechs vs. Aliens version of X-COM. I’m way into the whole set up of each run being a new universe in which you have to try to save as many people as possible, and each turn of a map feels just as vital as even the most important moments in other games. I have never played FTL, but this game definitely makes me want to check it out. Recommended if you like Mechs, feeling really smart, or just want the experience of knowing the extinction of humanity was your fault because you accidentally knocked your own mech into a building and managed to destroy both of those things.
Monster Hunter: World- Monster Hunter World takes everything I loved about Shadow of the Colossus and cranked it up to 100. The scale of the monsters you’re fighting is jaw dropping, the overall style makes everything pop, and the cutscene every time you order food at the canteen is a joy each time you see it. I feel like I only scratched the surface of this dense game, but just the way it feels had me hooked from the outset. Even though I couldn’t get past the Anjanath, I still really enjoyed my time with this game. Highest recommendation possible, but if you want to be exposed to the truth that cats are the only reason humans are capable of doing anything useful.
NJPW Mobile Game- When I first launched this game and I was greeted with Toru Yano’s glorious face holding the copyright info, I was immediately ready to name this game my Game of the Year. But as I played it for about 20 minutes, I wasn’t really into what it was doing and put it down, only to forget that it existed in the first place. Recommended if you want to see loading screens that give extremely useful advice to aspiring pro wrestlers.
Radical heights- Imagine Fortnite but in the context of a game show, but also with BMX bikes that you can totally do sick tricks on. I played about 2 games and then remembered that battle royales aren’t my thing. Recommended if you like Fortnite, but you need to have narrative justifications in your games.
Red Dead Redemption 2- During the hour-long conversation about this game on Giant Bombs Game of the Year podcast, the great Vinny Caravella said of this game, “Constantly impressive, but not constantly entertaining”. I think that I the most succinct way of putting my feeling on this game into words. I loved riding around the world to find hunting or fishing spots. I have 14 markers on my map, all leading to spots to grab some breathtaking pictures of the landscape. I loved how every inch of the massive world was dripping with details both big and small. I loved almost everything about this game. Then I got deeper into the story and realized that I was in for Rockstar’s formulaic and boring mission structure for a whole lot of hours. As much as I enjoyed the incredible narrative, my driving force for finishing this game was me just wanting to be done with it. Red Dead Redemption 2 is seriously maybe 3 design choices away from being possibly the best video game ever made. Highest recommendation possible, especially if you want to have a contest to see how far you can launch yourself by slamming your horse into a rock.
Vampyr- Much like all of DONTNOD’s games, this one has an incredible idea behind it. Much like all of their games outside of the Life is Strange series, it falls just short of realizing the potential of those ideas. Honestly I enjoyed my time with Vampyr, but it’s something that I will remember alongside Remember Me for being an okay game that could have been so much more. Recommended if you’re a fan of getting to know people so they taste better when you eat them.
Game of the Year
Hitman 2- As I said before, the 2016 reboot of Hitman is one of the top 5 games of this generation. This is 100% more of that, but better. They even went as far as to add the gameplay improvements into the old maps to make an infinitely replayable experience. To paraphrase Waypoint’s Austin Walker, Hitman is a game of incredible clockwork worlds and you are the wrench being thrown into the gears. As much fun as it is to follow the mission stories to kill your targets in such ways as dressing up as flamingo to get a secretive meeting with them to do your business, or pushing the target into a cocaine machine and turn him into a brick of super-cocaine, it’s more fun when you start breaking the gears and causing as much chaos as humanly possible.
Games to look forward to in 2019
The rest of Life is Strange 2
2018 game rankings for those who absolutely must know
13. NJPW Mobile game
12. Detroit
11. Fallout 76
10. Radical Heights
9. Far Cry 5
8. Vampyr
7. God of War
6. Captain Spirit
5. Into the Breach
4. Monster Hunter World
3. Donut County
2. Red Dead Redemption 2
1. Hitman 2
Log in to comment