Game of The Year 2014 Users Choice
OK. I think this is finalized.
Unordered Honorable Mentions:
MASSIVE CHALICE - From the two games I played of it, it was really good despite being very incomplete. It didn't really feel incomplete just unpolished. I would be surprised if it did not make my GOTY list next year.
2048 - I play a lot of this game. Probably more than any other game this year. I enjoyed it more than Threes and come back to it frequently. This is especially true once I realized how to play it well. Now I'm sure there are people who can break it easily, but I'm glad of my skill level and find the game to be a nice refreshing experience whenever I want to focus on something else for while.
Nidhogg - I didn't play enough of this game to put it on the main list, but whenever I did I really enjoyed myself. It's great.
Shovel Knight - There was a lot of Shovel Knight that I didn't like enough to put on the main list. Namely how so much of the level design relied on instant death traps. However I enjoyed the boss encounters, the music, the graphics, and world enough that I think it should be at least mentioned.
The Yawhg - This was released in 2013 so it doesn't count. Also I only played it twice. But those times I've played it were some of best times with a multiplayer game this year.
Transistor - Transistor could have been amazing, but I was just not terribly impressed by it. It has beautiful art, a great sound track, and a real interesting ability system. But the story and world just aren't set up or executed well enough.