Holy shit.  Jeff was right, this game looks fantastic.  Open ended pirate games = awesome.  I wonder if they'll have an economy system or if it's purely action oriented.  It gives me a feeling of what Pirates! or Uncharted Waters would be like if they were made using today's tech.

It does look surprisingly good. I think the PoTC name is only there to get it some publicity and hopefully won't have much to do with its overall quality.

I hope the enviroments get less... empty looking, I want to explore whole jungles, damnit!

Really want to see a ship battle in that

it looks so good, i hope it delivers

I don't think it looks greatly like Fable but I can see where you're coming from. This trailer looks good and I really want to like this game, I hope it's as good as it has the potential to be.

Looks really good. Loved the first pirates rpg too, so really looking forward to this one.

This looks surprisingly awesome. Probably because it doesn't appear to have any relation to the movies beyond the locations.