I'm not going to deny that the setlist for GH: Metallica is my favorite out of any GH game ever, but as a die-hard fan there are some songs I would've loved to see in the game, by Metallica and other artists. 
 
Metallica Tracks:
-Bleeding Me: I'm probably one of only a few people who think this song is amazing, but damn it, they only chose one song from Load and it was the one everyone knew.
-The Outlaw Torn: A near-11 minute epic from the Load album that would be oh so fun to play on a plastic guitar. It's too bad it didn't get a lot of exposure (pretty much the case with the entire Load album)
-Harvester of Sorrow: One of the best songs off of ...And Justice for All, and it isn't in the game!!!!!! This is truly language of the mad!

Non-Metallica Tracks:

Once by Pearl Jam: I dunno if Metallica ever did a full-on tour with them, but they have played with them. Also, Once is just that good of a song.
Any Misfits Song: The lyrical themes of the Misfits aren't exactly family-friendly, but if they were able to get a Slayer song in the game, then they sure as hell could've gotten a song by a band that HEAVILY influenced Metallica. Metallica has covered three of their songs, and yet the only remnant of the Misfits in the set list is the track "Mother of Mercy" by Samhain, Misfit's singer Glenn Danzig's short-lived side project.
Holy Wars...The Punishment Due by Megadeth: Yeah, yeah, I know it'd never happen. But Holy Wars is an amazing fucking song, best song Megadeth has ever written. If only Harmonix had put out Rust in Peace instead of Peace Sells as full album DLC.....sigh.

So there you have it, what songs would you like to have seen in the GHM set list?

wow i thought that Harvester was in the game but after looking at the song list i was like "WHAT!" im surprised they didn't put it in the game

They missed Breadfan. That may be the biggest crime of all.

Any song by Megadeth and Anthrax. Why leave out two bands of the Big 4 Thrash bands? (I'd gladly take Caught in the Mosh and Tornado of Souls)

Harvester of Sorrow and Damage Inc

Call of Ktulu. That is a fucking opus of epic portions and they left it out?? I was so incensed that I almost considered not buying this game but I couldn't resist Seek and Destroy with lead guitar action. Overall I'm quite happy with the song list, it's comprehensive and includes their biggest hits. Guess they can't make it commercial and pander to the hardcore fans at the same time?

"Call of Ktulu. That is a fucking opus of epic portions and they left it out?? I was so incensed that I almost considered not buying this game but I couldn't resist Seek and Destroy with lead guitar action. Overall I'm quite happy with the song list, it's comprehensive and includes their biggest hits. Guess they can't make it commercial and pander to the hardcore fans at the same time?
"

Harvester

@ Everyones_A_Critic:

"@ Everyones_A_Critic:

What's with the Load-love? ;-)

 

"

Actually, Everyone's...you hit the nail on the head with what I thought.  Bleeding Me and The Outlaw Torn feel like massive omissions, and of course....there's no ...And Justice for All on there.  Not including that song is a GLARING omission.

"They missed Breadfan. That may be the biggest crime of all."

Whiskey in the Jar needed to be in this game.  The guitar part isn't insane or anything; the song is just awesome.

"@ Everyones_A_Critic:

What's with the Load-love? ;-)

Agree about Harvester... and agree about that particular Megadeth song too. Kind of sucks that the bands can't stand each other... well, Dave Mustang anyway - but he's pretty much Megadeth anyways.

"

"EvilDingo said:

"@ Everyones_A_Critic:

What's with the Load-love? ;-)

Agree about Harvester... and agree about that particular Megadeth song too. Kind of sucks that the bands can't stand each other... well, Dave Mustang anyway - but he's pretty much Megadeth anyways.

"

I have a serious question.Why does everyone hate load and reload?"

"RHCPfan24 said:

"They missed Breadfan. That may be the biggest crime of all."

I agree"